My approach to the digital story versus the analytical research paper was extremely different. The biggest difference came in the preparation. The digital story writing involved no preparation besides reading what other students had already posted. The analytical research paper involved several steps and forms of research. The page I wrote for the digital story came completely from my thoughts. The analytical research paper included thoughts of the author of the short story I was writing on and the thoughts of the authors of the secondary sources I used. Creative writing was a much less structured experience than research paper writing. The digital story was a chance to just write from your own creative mind with no argument, while the analytical research paper was much more in-depth project where you are always seeking to back up your argument.
The events leading to these two different types of writing differed extremely. For the analytical research paper, there was a lengthy writing process. It first involved picking a primary source to write an analysis on. Then, we found secondary sources and talked about how they were related to the details we explained in our analysis. We then integrated these sources and made arguments about our primary sources. Each of these steps served as a guide in how we were supposed to write our paper. The digital story writing was completely different. It was based on immediate thoughts rather than building an argument over an extended amount of time. There was basically no preparation and hardly any guidelines to follow.
This difference in immediate thoughts versus developed thoughts also made a huge impact on the two different types of writing. At the beginning of the analytical research paper process, I had no idea what I was going to write about. I did not really come up with a concrete argument until we did the secondary source integration. This step helped me draw a connection and create an argument. The digital story writing was more of a result of my reaction. My group and I read what the groups had already written, and we simply just wrote what we felt should happen next in the story. There was no research and no reflection; we just developed thoughts and wrote all in one step.
In the end, both these types of writing style were very beneficial. The analytical research paper was thought provoking and lead to the writing of a unique paper. The digital story telling also lead to a unique form of writing, but it did not hold the same strength that the writing in the analytical research had. The purpose of the digital story was simply to just tell a tale. The purpose of the research paper was to come up with an argument and back it up. This is the difference between creative writing and research paper writing. The flexibility of the structure determines how your mind thinks. For the digital story, you just wrote about your gut reactions to what you had already read. You may think differently of the subject later, but you have already written what you felt at first. The research paper gives you time to reflect on your initial thoughts and critique them. You can alter them over time to formulate your final idea. Both of these types of writings are both beneficial and important. Which style you choose is dependent on the topic you are writing on. If it is just a story, the creative writing style is a better style. If you are writing on something you feel strongly about, you should do the research style of writing.
Just like you, I had no idea what I was going to write about for our analytical research paper assignment. I didn’t even know where to begin so I started thinking about the novels that I have read throughout my life. One novel came to mind immediately, which was a sign. I decided to pick that specific novel as my topic because it turned out to be one of my favorite books. However, I did struggle with coming up with an argument. Finally, I was able to come up with a strong argument when we were assigned the secondary source integration.
ReplyDeleteMy group was the first group to write for the digital storytelling project. While it involved no preparation, it still wasn’t all that easy to come up with the first page for a story that would eventually be seven or eight pages long. My fellow peers and I fed off of each other’s ideas to come up with a fantasy story. We decided to leave the ending pretty open so that the next group could take the story any direction they wished.
I agree that the digital story project and analytical research paper are very different. The research paper needed way more preparation. First, you had to pick a topic and then most likely read the book or watch the movie that you chose. After carefully going through your source you had to come up with some central idea and figure out how you could prove it. At least for me this was no easy task. All I had to do for the digital story project was read the previous pages and come with ideas. I was in the last group so we had to figure out how to bring the story to a close. At first this seemed daunting, but once we got started it was not too bad.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the idea that if you feel strongly about something then you should write a research paper about it as opposed to just creative writing. What you have to say in a research paper would be better received than if you write about it in something that is not supported by other sources. Though writing something just doing a free write style would be more free feeling, a research paper could possible sway people and be more informative. Though most people may not feel smarter after reading something I wrote, I would enjoy writing something creative more.
ReplyDeleteI agree that there was a lot of preparation involved in writing the analytical research paper. We had to spend time finding outside sources and researching our topic. In the digital writing story, we could just sit down and write whatever came to our minds. I also agree that both types of writing are beneficial. There is a time and a place to use both styles. It was nice to write the digital story and have my own writing style be looked at. For a research paper, the way you present the information you found on your topic is being looked at more than your own writing style.
ReplyDelete